Note: Froggy originally gave ratings between 1 to 5. However, I (Banshee) multiplied all by 2.




map 1 (Audjo)
layout 5 
eye candy 4 
playability 7 
overall 5 


basic map, no impressive features
working tunnels!
no active AI
strategic atks possible
veinhole monsters display wrong
conclusion: there are tunnels, but map needs much more detail 



map 2 (Carnotaurus)
l 4 
e 6 
p 4 
o 5 


detailed w/ tiberium
side balance issues
top left dominates
bottom left is too far from tiberium
conclusion: the map is okay, there are balance issues to strike 



map 3 (Fremen5)
l 4 
e 6 
p 2 
0 4 


obvious invisible lightposts (at least put terrain over them; I can't build over them)
too many meteor storms (this trigger is way overdone)
detailed map
tiberium imbalance



map 4 (Aurora196)
l 6 
e 7 
p 6 
o 7 


unrealistically green everywhere
limited build space
tiberium too remote in some places
plenty of detail, creatures
ambience is good (noise from creatures)
old bases nice touch, though capturability leaves balance issues (fix by making them friendly to all sides?)
reveal map is too powerful for the capturable radar
hunter seekers likely to target civvies
some strategic possibility 



map 5 (J4m3sb0nd)
l 6 
e 8 
p 8 
o 8 


very detailed
too many meteor storms
tiberium too isolated from bases
nightstalkers are cool :D
bridge vs terrain slight error noticed
overall nice tiberium based map



map 6 (Sk8erkid)
l 2 
e 2 
p 2 
o 2 (no, it's not the water tiles, it was a very unimpressive map) 


overconfident?
bridges incomplete
undetailed, unimpressive
overall bad map



map 7 (Clazzy)
l 8 
e 9 
p 9 
o 9 


like civilian towns
detailed, lots of ups and downs
overall nice detailed map
no real noticable imbalances
nice tiberium farm :D



map 8 (Lazerace7)
undefined (can't review) 


will not rate if I can't even play it - what's the point? 



map 9 (Wes.com)
l 8 
e 8 
p 8 
o 8 


nice train trigger
very detailed, no real imbalance issues



map 10 (Tesla7zap)
l 4 
e 7 
p 4 
o 5 


okay, but not enough tiberium
center capture is too good



map 11 (Terror)
l 5 
e 3 
p 4 
o 4 


very basic... did not take any notes on because of the detail of the other maps. very rushed looking.